Secret poster
7.5
Arcplot Score
Unverified

Secret

2007101 minNot Rated
Director: Jay Chou

Ye Xiang Lun is a music student majoring in piano who just transferred to Tamkang, a school famous for its musically-talented students, especially those who play piano. On his first day of school, he hears a mysterious melody being played; following it, he meets Lu Xiao Yu, another piano major. When he asks her about the song she was playing, she tells him that it is a secret that cannot be told. The two form a friendship that quickly evolves into a romantic relationship. However, there is more to Xiao Yu than initially meets the eye of Ye Xiang Lun.

Revenue$9.0M

The film earned $9.0M at the global box office.

IMDb7.5TMDb7.6
Popularity3.3
Awards

4 wins & 3 nominations

Plot Structure

Story beats plotted across runtime

Act ISetupAct IIConfrontationAct IIIResolutionWorldbuilding3Resistance5Premise8Opposition10Crisis12Synthesis14124679111315
Color Timeline
Color timeline
Sound Timeline
Sound timeline
Threshold
Section
Plot Point

Narrative Arc

Emotional journey through the story's key moments

+42-1
0m25m50m75m100m
Plot Point
Act Threshold
Emotional Arc

Story Circle

Blueprint 15-beat structure

Loading Story Circle...

Arcplot Score Breakdown

Structural Adherence: Standard
8.9/10
4.5/10
4/10
Overall Score7.5/10

Weighted: Precision (70%) + Arc (15%) + Theme (15%)

Secret (2007) exhibits deliberately positioned story structure, characteristic of Jay Chou's storytelling approach. This structural analysis examines how the film's 15-point plot structure maps to proven narrative frameworks across 1 hour and 41 minutes. With an Arcplot score of 7.5, the film showcases strong structural fundamentals.

Structural Analysis

The Status Quo at 1 minutes (1% through the runtime) establishes Hsiao-lun arrives at his new school, Tamkang Secondary School, as a transfer student. He wanders the quiet campus with his father, a new music teacher, establishing his identity as a talented but reserved pianist in an unfamiliar environment.. Notably, this early placement immediately immerses viewers in the story world.

The inciting incident occurs at 12 minutes when Hsiao-lun hears mysterious piano music coming from the old practice room. He investigates and sees Hsueh-yu playing a hauntingly beautiful melody. This encounter disrupts his ordinary school life and draws him toward the mystery that will transform everything.. At 11% through the film, this Disruption aligns precisely with traditional story structure. This beat shifts the emotional landscape, launching the protagonist into the central conflict.

The First Threshold at 24 minutes marks the transition into Act II, occurring at 24% of the runtime. This demonstrates the protagonist's commitment to Hsiao-lun actively chooses to pursue Hsueh-yu despite the mysteries surrounding her. He engages her in conversation, shares music with her, and commits to building a relationship with this enigmatic girl, stepping fully into the romantic storyline that will define Act 2., moving from reaction to action.

At 51 minutes, the Midpoint arrives at 50% of the runtime—precisely centered, creating perfect narrative symmetry. Significantly, this crucial beat Hsueh-yu suddenly disappears without explanation. Hsiao-lun searches for her frantically but no one at school seems to know who she is or remember her. This false defeat raises the stakes dramatically and shifts the story from romance to mystery - what is really going on?., fundamentally raising what's at risk. The emotional intensity shifts, dividing the narrative into clear before-and-after phases.

The Collapse moment at 75 minutes (74% through) represents the emotional nadir. Here, Hsiao-lun learns the full truth: Hsueh-yu has been time-traveling to see him via the piano in the old practice room, but in her timeline (1979), she is suffering from asthma and her health is deteriorating. The "whiff of death" - he realizes she may be dying or already dead in the present, and their love seems doomed by the laws of time., demonstrates the protagonist at their lowest point. This beat's placement in the final quarter sets up the climactic reversal.

The Second Threshold at 80 minutes initiates the final act resolution at 79% of the runtime. Hsiao-lun realizes he can use the same piano to travel back to 1979 to save Hsueh-yu. The synthesis: combining his musical ability (original skill) with the knowledge of time travel (what he learned from their relationship). He makes the choice to risk everything and go back to her time., demonstrating the transformation achieved throughout the journey.

Emotional Journey

Secret's emotional architecture traces a deliberate progression across 15 carefully calibrated beats.

Narrative Framework

This structural analysis employs a 15-point narrative structure framework that maps key story moments. By mapping Secret against these established plot points, we can identify how Jay Chou utilizes or subverts traditional narrative conventions. The plot point approach reveals not only adherence to structural principles but also creative choices that distinguish Secret within the drama genre.

Comparative Analysis

Additional drama films include Eye for an Eye, South Pacific and Kiss of the Spider Woman.

Plot Points by Act

Act I

Setup
1

Status Quo

1 min1.0%0 tone

Hsiao-lun arrives at his new school, Tamkang Secondary School, as a transfer student. He wanders the quiet campus with his father, a new music teacher, establishing his identity as a talented but reserved pianist in an unfamiliar environment.

2

Theme

4 min4.2%0 tone

A student mentions the old piano room's mysterious nature, warning that "some things are better left unknown." This foreshadows the film's central tension between the desire to know secrets and the consequences of revealing them.

3

Worldbuilding

1 min1.0%0 tone

Hsiao-lun settles into school life, meeting classmates, exploring the music building, and establishing his routine. His father teaches music and encourages him to participate. We see the school's culture, the dynamics between students, and Hsiao-lun's quiet, observant nature as he navigates this new world.

4

Disruption

12 min11.5%+1 tone

Hsiao-lun hears mysterious piano music coming from the old practice room. He investigates and sees Hsueh-yu playing a hauntingly beautiful melody. This encounter disrupts his ordinary school life and draws him toward the mystery that will transform everything.

5

Resistance

12 min11.5%+1 tone

Hsiao-lun becomes fascinated with Hsueh-yu, trying to find her around school and learn more about her. She appears and disappears mysteriously. He debates whether to pursue this connection, encouraged by his growing feelings but confused by her elusiveness and the strange circumstances surrounding her appearances.

Act II

Confrontation
6

First Threshold

24 min24.0%+2 tone

Hsiao-lun actively chooses to pursue Hsueh-yu despite the mysteries surrounding her. He engages her in conversation, shares music with her, and commits to building a relationship with this enigmatic girl, stepping fully into the romantic storyline that will define Act 2.

7

Mirror World

28 min28.1%+3 tone

Hsiao-lun and Hsueh-yu's relationship deepens through shared musical moments in the practice room. She represents the thematic mirror: the tension between living in the present and being haunted by the past, between revealing truth and keeping secrets.

8

Premise

24 min24.0%+2 tone

The romantic relationship blossoms. Hsiao-lun and Hsueh-yu spend time together, share musical duets, and develop genuine connection. This is the "promise of the premise" - the beautiful, mysterious romance the audience came for, filled with piano melodies, youthful love, and the enchantment of their secret meetings.

9

Midpoint

51 min50.0%+2 tone

Hsueh-yu suddenly disappears without explanation. Hsiao-lun searches for her frantically but no one at school seems to know who she is or remember her. This false defeat raises the stakes dramatically and shifts the story from romance to mystery - what is really going on?

10

Opposition

51 min50.0%+2 tone

Hsiao-lun investigates Hsueh-yu's disappearance, discovering clues that point to an impossible truth. He finds old graduation photos, uncovers the school's history, and pieces together that Hsueh-yu existed in 1979. The mystery deepens as he confronts the reality that his love transcends time, creating seemingly insurmountable opposition.

11

Collapse

75 min74.0%+1 tone

Hsiao-lun learns the full truth: Hsueh-yu has been time-traveling to see him via the piano in the old practice room, but in her timeline (1979), she is suffering from asthma and her health is deteriorating. The "whiff of death" - he realizes she may be dying or already dead in the present, and their love seems doomed by the laws of time.

12

Crisis

75 min74.0%+1 tone

Hsiao-lun processes the devastating reality in darkness and despair. He must decide whether to accept loss or take action. The emotional weight of loving someone across time, unreachable yet so real, threatens to break him. He sits in the old practice room, surrounded by memories and impossibility.

Act III

Resolution
13

Second Threshold

80 min79.2%+2 tone

Hsiao-lun realizes he can use the same piano to travel back to 1979 to save Hsueh-yu. The synthesis: combining his musical ability (original skill) with the knowledge of time travel (what he learned from their relationship). He makes the choice to risk everything and go back to her time.

14

Synthesis

80 min79.2%+2 tone

Hsiao-lun travels to 1979, finds young Hsueh-yu, and tries to change her fate. The finale plays out as he confronts the rules of time travel, makes the ultimate sacrifice, and resolves the central tension between secret and revelation, past and present, love and loss. The time paradox resolves in a bittersweet resolution.

15

Transformation

100 min99.0%+3 tone

The closing image mirrors the opening: the old piano room, now understood. Hsueh-yu (in the present timeline) remembers, revealing the transformation - what began as a mysterious encounter has become a timeless love that transcended temporal boundaries. The secret is finally understood and its cost revealed.